XPO Logistics, which arranged a 2020 load of plasticware from New Jersey to California but hired another company to haul it, owed no nondelegable duty to a driver who was asleep in the truck’s bunk when it crashed in Oklahoma, California’s Second District Court of Appeal held on January 16, 2026. The opinion in Hu v. XPO Logistics joins a run of rulings and verdicts that test how far responsibility for a delivery crash reaches beyond the driver.
How Last-Mile Contractor Chains Split Responsibility in California
Amazon Logistics moved 6.3 billion parcels in the United States in 2024, behind only the Postal Service, according to the Pitney Bowes Parcel Shipping Index, and much of that volume travels in vans run by Delivery Service Partners (DSPs), small firms that hire their own drivers and, according to an Amazon statement quoted by the ABA Journal, must carry business auto, cargo and other coverage. Civil Code § 2338, enacted in 1872, makes a principal answer to third persons for an agent’s negligence “in the transaction of the business of the agency,” while § 1714 sets the general duty of ordinary care.
Negligent hiring and entrustment claims, which rest on a company’s own conduct, do not require the driver to be its employee. Landver Law, a personal injury firm on Wilshire Boulevard in Beverly Hills with offices also listed in Los Angeles, Orange County, San Diego and Palm Springs, describes its delivery truck accident lawyer work as covering step vans, box trucks and personal cars used for deliveries, and it lists vehicle owners and maintenance providers among the parties such claims can reach.
Respondeat Superior and the Control Test
The leading California Supreme Court test on control came out of a Ventura County case about a pizza franchise rather than a traffic collision. In Patterson v. Domino’s Pizza (2014), a 4-3 majority held that a franchisor answers for a franchisee’s workers only where it keeps a general right of control over hiring, discipline and the day-to-day aspects of their work.
Labor Code § 2775, which put the ABC test from Dynamex into statute through AB 5 in 2019, presumes that a paid worker is an employee unless the hiring entity proves all three prongs, although it governs wage and employment statutes, and negligence suits still lean mainly on common-law control factors. Its reach over trucking was settled on June 30, 2022, when the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear California Trucking Association v. Bonta; the association said at the time that “gasoline has been poured on the fire” of the supply chain crisis.
Couriers working through apps such as DoorDash fall under Proposition 22, which the California Supreme Court upheld unanimously in Castellanos v. State of California on July 25, 2024. Business and Professions Code § 7451 says a qualifying driver is “an independent contractor and not an employee or agent” of the network company.
Contract Delivery Models and Commercial Vehicle Liability on California Roads
Licensed carriers have owed a safety duty that cannot be passed to a subcontractor since Eli v. Murphy (1952). In Serna v. Pettey Leach Trucking (2003), which began when Harrison Poultry in Georgia asked the defendant to arrange a shipment of frozen poultry to California, the Second District held the arranging carrier responsible for the independent firm that hauled the load, while Hill Brothers Chemical Co. v. Superior Court (2004) refused to extend that duty to a private carrier that hired a for-hire trucker. The Hu panel treated XPO’s delivery-timing instructions as part of brokering and called a federal cargo-liability test “an apple to the pertinent law’s orange.”
Amazon’s lawyers have told juries that DSP drivers work for independent companies and are not Amazon’s agents. The Beverly Hills firm’s Amazon truck accident lawyer page describes that position and separates Flex drivers using their own cars, DSP vans and Freight Partner tractor-trailers, noting that claims against Amazon itself generally turn on evidence of control over routes, timing or discipline. Reported results include the following.
- In San Bernardino County, jurors awarded $5 million on June 8, 2022, to Anita Sun Eisenberg, a beauty aesthetician who had appeared on Shark Tank, after Amazon admitted liability for a 2018 parking-lot crash.
- A Gwinnett County, Georgia, jury in Bradfield v. Amazon Logistics (August 2024) returned $16.2 million for an eight-year-old dragged 21 feet by a DSP van and put 85% of the fault on Amazon.
- Malcolm Carnwath, a 78-year-old retired realtor, received $56 million from a Middlesex County, Massachusetts, jury on July 22, 2026, after Amazon stipulated to liability five days before trial.
Only the Eisenberg award came from a California court, and none of the three is an appellate ruling. In a separate federal labor matter, the NLRB’s Los Angeles region found in August 2024 that Amazon jointly employed drivers at Battle Tested Strategies in Palmdale, who in 2023 had become the first Amazon delivery drivers to join the Teamsters, and Amazon spokesperson Eileen Hards said the union was “misrepresenting the facts.”
Commercial Auto Insurance Layers Behind Pickups, Vans and Box Trucks
NHTSA counted 5,472 people killed and an estimated 153,452 injured in 2023 in crashes involving large trucks, which the agency defines as vehicles over 10,000 pounds gross vehicle weight rating, the same weight California uses for its commercial permit line.
- Vehicle Code § 16056 has required $30,000 per person, $60,000 per accident and $15,000 for property damage since January 1, 2025, the first increase since 1967, with $50,000, $100,000 and $25,000 scheduled for 2035.
- Under Vehicle Code § 34601, a Motor Carrier of Property Permit covers motortrucks with two or more axles over 10,000 pounds and any vehicle hauling property for pay, and the CHP’s permit FAQ notes that a pickup counts as a motortruck, subject to some exemptions.
- Delivery network companies must keep $1,000,000 per occurrence in auto liability coverage during engaged time under Business and Professions Code § 7455(f)(1).
How Investigators Reconstruct Delivery Crashes
Fleet video now sits beside the CHP or police collision report in many of these cases. Amazon rolled out Netradyne’s Driveri cameras, whose name is pronounced “driver eye,” across DSP vans in 2021, and a training video described by CNBC said they record “100% of the time” while drivers are on route.
Those records are tested against Vehicle Code § 21703, which bars following “more closely than is reasonable and prudent,” and § 22500, which restricts double parking, while Evidence Code § 669 can create a presumption of negligence when a safety statute is broken. Under Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975), a claimant’s share of fault reduces damages without barring recovery.
Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1 generally allows two years to file a personal injury suit, slightly longer than the time Bradfield took to go from crash to verdict. Government Code § 911.2 sets six months for claims involving public entities, and other exceptions exist.
Conclusion
California courts still decide contractor delivery crashes on their facts, through control tests, carriers’ nondelegable duties and Proposition 22. Developments to follow include any California appellate opinion on retailer control of DSP fleets, the NLRB case over Amazon’s Palmdale drivers, and the insurance minimums set to rise in 2035.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.











